I asked for a list of roofers and here is what i have to offer up as a consolidated list

I chose to go with M&T because he showed up and gave me the best quote, and found the actual problem.  Also he can come back and fix it in a couple of days. 

The 2 I have marked as "I do not recommend" failed to find the actual issue on my roof and wanted to charge me for a new tin roof I did not need or some kind of coatings or other silliness one should not need.  Also one of those 2 told me it would be 12 weeks before they could get the crew out to do the repair - that is utterly useless, who has 3 months to wait on a roof repair?

Their quotes were astronomical and would not have actually fixed the leak in my roof , so my advice is to avoid them.

Have a wonderful holiday season