Apologies that I am sending the requested summary out later than I had planned, I am being eaten alive by exam season. The options I received for recycling pumpkins are listed below:

The zoo (I did not contact them so I cannot confirm this)

Allegheny Goatscape (there is a herd at the Garfield Community Farm, which is where I ended up taking the pumpkins)

Oakmont

Hope Haven may be taking pumpkins (I did not contact them)

Hope that this helps,

EM
--