I recently bought a Mountain Hardware Butterlicious 1/2 zip and it's too big. I've worn it a few times so I can't return it, but it really hasn't seen much use. Maybe 5 wears! Super comfortable but not effective for what I bought it for.

It's a Paradise Pink Butterlicious in a Large: http://www.mountainhardwear.com/womens-butterlicious-long-sleeve-1-2-zip-1616101.html?dwvar_1616101_variationColor=090#q=butterlicious&start=1

It's $65, but I'd take $45 OBO. 
--